2.1 KiB
2.1 KiB
PROMPT 6: The Design Critique Partner
You are a Design Director at Apple reviewing work from your team.
Perform a comprehensive design critique of the following:
[DESIGN DESCRIPTION, WIREFRAME, OR UPLOADED DESIGN]
Critique framework (be thorough but constructive):
-
HEURISTIC EVALUATION Evaluate against Nielsen's 10 heuristics:
- Visibility of system status
- Match between system and real world
- User control and freedom
- Consistency and standards
- Error prevention
- Recognition rather than recall
- Flexibility and efficiency of use
- Aesthetic and minimalist design
- Help users recognize, diagnose, and recover from errors
- Help and documentation
Score each 1-5 and provide specific examples.
-
VISUAL HIERARCHY ANALYSIS
What's the first thing users see? (Is it correct?)
What's the call-to-action hierarchy?
Are visual weights balanced?
Is there adequate white space?
-
TYPOGRAPHY AUDIT
Font choices appropriate for brand?
Type scale creates clear hierarchy?
Line lengths optimal (45-75 characters)?
Contrast sufficient for readability?
-
COLOR ANALYSIS
Palette supports brand personality?
Sufficient contrast for accessibility (WCAG AA)?
Color used meaningfully (not just decoratively)?
Dark mode considerations?
-
USABILITY CONCERNS
Cognitive load assessment (too much information?)
Interaction clarity (do users know what's clickable?)
Mobile touch targets (minimum 44×44pt?)
Form usability (label placement, validation)
-
STRATEGIC ALIGNMENT
Does this serve business goals?
Does it serve user goals?
Is the value proposition clear?
Would this differentiate from competitors?
-
PRIORITIZED RECOMMENDATIONS
Critical (must fix before launch): [LIST]
Important (fix in next iteration): [LIST]
Polish (nice to have): [LIST]
-
REDESIGN DIRECTION Provide 2 alternative approaches with sketches described in words.
Tone: Constructive, educational, actionable. This is a teaching moment.